Tue, Nov 17
57°F Fredericksburg, VA
Go FXBG
Home / Articles / Virginia sits out the federal scholarship tax credit in 2027: the program, the decision, and both sides
Virginia

Virginia sits out the federal scholarship tax credit in 2027: the program, the decision, and both sides

Virginia will sit out the first year of the new federal scholarship tax credit. Gov. Abigail Spanberger will not complete the enrollment her predecessor began in January, so no Vi...

Alex Wilson
Alex Wilson
NDSM, TownSites | REALTOR® | Local Market & Business Growth Strategist
November 17, 2026
Virginia sits out the federal scholarship tax credit in 2027: the program, the decision, and both sides

Fredericksburg · Community Photo

Virginia will sit out the first year of the new federal scholarship tax credit. Gov. Abigail Spanberger will not complete the enrollment her predecessor began in January, so no Virginia organization will be on the federal list of scholarship-granting organizations for 2027 — and no Virginia student can receive one of these scholarships next year, with a narrow exception for some military dependents.

Go FXBG reported Saturday that Virginia would sit out the program in 2027. This is the fuller picture: how the program works, why the governor opted out, what each side says, and what it means for families here.

The Washington Post first reported the decision on the evening of Friday, Nov. 13. Spanberger's office confirmed it on Monday, Nov. 16. The decision is not final: the window to file the list of organizations stays open until Feb. 15, 2027, and each year is a separate decision, so 2028 would be a fresh choice.

How the program works

The program was enacted July 4, 2025, as part of the One Big Beautiful Bill Act — Section 70411, now Section 25F of the tax code. It is known by several names: the Educational Choice for Children Act, the Education Freedom Tax Credit, and the Federal Scholarship Tax Credit. It takes effect for donations made on or after Jan. 1, 2027.

From that date, an individual taxpayer gets a dollar-for-dollar, non-refundable federal tax credit of up to $1,700 a year for cash donated to a scholarship-granting organization on a participating state's list. A married couple filing jointly can claim up to $3,400 if each spouse gives — though that joint figure comes from proposed regulations that are not yet final. The credit can reduce a tax bill to zero but not below it, unused credit carries forward for up to five years, and it is available whether or not the donor itemizes. Donations made in 2026 do not qualify.

A scholarship-granting organization must be a nonprofit charity on a participating state's list. It has to spend at least 90% of its income on scholarships and serve at least 10 students who do not all attend the same school. Donations cannot be earmarked for a named student.

Eligible students are in kindergarten through 12th grade, eligible to enroll in a public school, living in a household with income at or below 300% of the area median income, and living in a participating state. Treasury estimates about 96% of children would qualify — so this is not a narrow low-income program.

Scholarships cover tuition and fees, academic tutoring, special-needs services, books and supplies, technology and internet access, transportation, uniforms and after-school programs. That last point matters: this is not only private-school tuition. A public-school student can use a scholarship for tutoring, special-needs services, books or after-school care.

There is no national cap on the program. Treasury projects that by 2030 it could support nearly $26 billion in contributions a year, funding as many as 2.2 million scholarships. The cost to the federal Treasury is disputed: Congress's Joint Committee on Taxation put it at up to $4 billion a year; other estimates run far higher.

Why Virginia opted out

Spanberger's office told the Post: “The Spanberger Administration, at this point, does not believe this program would benefit students in public schools, and the Commonwealth will not be participating this year.” Her office added, “Public money should go to public education.” It pointed to $2 billion in new education funding in Virginia's 2026–28 budget and said the governor would keep monitoring the program to assess its effects in other states. Lt. Gov. Ghazala Hashmi backed the decision, saying the program would draw resources away from public schools.

The decision reverses what her predecessor set in motion. On Jan. 9, 2026, outgoing Gov. Glenn Youngkin filed Virginia's advance election with the Treasury Department, naming eight scholarship organizations and making Virginia the first state in the country to opt in. He added five more organizations on Jan. 16, the day before Spanberger took office. Her campaign education plan had pledged to “reject efforts to divert funding from public education to pay for voucher programs.”

The pressure built through the fall. On Oct. 2, the Virginia Education Association, the state teachers union, urged Spanberger not to complete the enrollment. On Oct. 9, she said the state's status “remains in question.” On Oct. 12, the Chesapeake School Board voted 7–2 to back participation. In late October, the IRS wrote to her office that Virginia “has not perfected its advance election submitted by the prior gubernatorial administration” — the portal for filing the scholarship list had not existed when Youngkin filed.

Virginia does not need to file a withdrawal. Under the federal rules it opts out simply by not sending the list of organizations by Feb. 15, 2027 — Treasury's own explanation of the rules describes exactly that route. That makes Virginia a first twice over: the first state to opt in, and the first whose election is on file but will not be completed.

Whether that is legal is now disputed. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent posted Nov. 15 that Virginia “is required under federal law to complete the administrative process” — the statute says a state that has elected to participate “shall provide” a list of organizations. Against that, the temporary regulations set no penalty for failing to file, and treat a state that never sends the list as not having elected to take part. Aaron Baer of the Virginia Christian Education Network called the move “heartless” and “likely illegal,” saying his organization's legal teams were evaluating it. No lawsuit had been filed as of Nov. 17. Analyst Andrew Rotherham put it this way: “Everyone saying Spanberger can't do this is also wrong.”

The case for taking part

Supporters — the Trump administration, Youngkin, religious-school groups, school-choice advocates and some Democrats — make four arguments.

Weekly Digest
Get the Newsletter

Every Thursday — local news, events, deals, and new listings. Free forever.

  • Choice and affordability. Families should be able to choose the education that fits their child regardless of income or ZIP code, supporters say. Baer: “Families should have the freedom to choose the education that best meets their children's needs, regardless of their income or ZIP code.”

  • It costs the state nothing. Scholarships are funded by private donations, not the state budget. Democrats for Education Reform, which backs the program, says every dollar is “in addition to existing school funding.”

  • Public-school students benefit too. This is the central factual dispute. The law explicitly covers public-school students for tutoring, special-needs services, books, technology and after-school care. Steven Cheeseman of the National Catholic Educational Association: “Most Catholic children attend public schools, and their educational needs matter deeply to us as well.” Democrats for Education Reform: “Public school kids stand to be among the program's biggest beneficiaries.” Analyst Chad Aldeman called Spanberger's framing “factually incorrect.”

  • It is bipartisan in principle. Supporters point to Democratic governors who opted in — Colorado's Jared Polis, who called it a “no-brainer,” New York's Kathy Hochul and New Mexico's Michelle Lujan Grisham — and to former Obama education secretary Arne Duncan, who has backed participation.

The case against

Critics — Spanberger's office, the Virginia Education Association and the national teachers unions, Americans United for Separation of Church and State, EdTrust and congressional Democrats — make a different case.

  • An enrollment and funding drain. Even though scholarships are privately donated, students who leave public schools take per-pupil funding with them while fixed costs — buildings, buses, staff — remain. The Virginia Education Association: “When students leave, a school's bills do not simply disappear … another wave of departures could put essential programs and entire schools at risk.”

  • It subsidizes families who can already afford private school. Rachel Laser of Americans United: the program will “funnel billions of taxpayer dollars into private, mostly religious schools to pay tuition for families who already can afford to send their kids to private schools.” EdTrust argues the rules are set up so the private-school sector benefits most, because established scholarship organizations have traditionally funneled money to private-school students.

  • No accountability or civil-rights protections. Private schools taking scholarship students are not subject to the same testing, reporting, non-discrimination and disability-rights obligations as public schools. Rep. Bobby Scott of Virginia: “By funneling these dollars into private schools, taxpayers are unwittingly paying for schools that neglect underprivileged communities, are permitted to ignore civil rights laws, and can freely discriminate against students without accountability.” States are also barred from adding their own safeguards under the proposed federal rules.

  • No state control. Virginia could not tailor the program to tutoring or after-school programs only, nor exclude organizations that fund private-school tuition. It would have to list every qualifying organization while taking on oversight duties — audits, investigations, removals — itself.

What it means for Virginia families

Here is the twist that surprises most people: Virginians can still claim the federal credit. A Virginian who donates cash to a scholarship organization on another participating state's list on or after Jan. 1, 2027 can claim the full $1,700 credit. The scholarships then go to students in that state. Four bordering states participate — North Carolina, Tennessee, Kentucky and West Virginia — so the practical question for a Virginia donor is which neighboring state's organization to give to.

Aldeman, who supports the program, put it bluntly: “Virginia donors can still donate to SGOs operating in other states. I know I will … But, with Governor Spanberger's recent decision, she has guaranteed that none of that money will benefit Virginia kids.”

There is one exception that matters here. A student who is the dependent of an Armed Forces member can receive a scholarship from the list of the state where the family legally lives — relevant in a state with Naval Station Norfolk and the Pentagon. A military family stationed in Virginia whose legal home is a participating state, such as Texas or Florida, can still receive a scholarship from that state's list.

Virginia's own, separate scholarship tax credit is unaffected. The Education Improvement Scholarships Tax Credit, in place since 2012, gives a 65% state tax credit for donations to approved scholarship foundations, capped at $25 million a year, for private-school scholarships. About 5,820 students took part in 2023–24 through roughly 40 approved foundations. It is a different, much narrower program — family income at or below 300% of the federal poverty guidelines — and the federal decision does not touch it.

As for how much money is at stake for Virginia, every figure in circulation is an advocate's estimate or a scenario, not an official forecast:

The money at stake — all estimates, none official
Source of estimateFigureWhat it assumes
Democrats for Education Reform$766 millionIf 15% of eligible Virginia taxpayers took part.
Teach CoalitionAbout $1.5 billionForegone scholarship dollars, per its CEO. No methodology was published.
Virginia Education AssociationAbout $940 million a yearScenario: if public-school operating support fell 4% as students moved. Not a forecast.
Chesapeake Education AssociationAbout $22 million a yearEstimated local exposure for Chesapeake alone.

None of these is an official forecast. The real amount depends on how many Virginians donate and how many students move — neither is knowable before the program runs.

Where other states stand

As of Nov. 13, the IRS listed 31 states as having filed advance elections, including Virginia — which will not complete its. New York's governor has announced the state will opt in, but the election had not been filed. Hawaii, Minnesota and Oregon have declined. In Arizona and Wisconsin, legislatures passed opt-in bills that their governors vetoed. Fourteen states and the District of Columbia are undecided, including California, Pennsylvania, Washington and New Jersey.

Where other states stand
StatusStates
Participating31 states on the IRS list as of Nov. 13 — Alabama, Alaska, Arkansas, Colorado, Florida, Georgia, Idaho, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Mexico, North Carolina, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Virginia*, West Virginia, Wyoming. *Virginia is listed but will not complete its election.
Announced, not yet filedNew York — Gov. Kathy Hochul said Oct. 9 she would opt in; the election had not been filed as of Nov. 13–16.
DeclinedHawaii, Minnesota, Oregon.
Opt-in bills vetoedArizona, Wisconsin.
Undecided14, including California, Pennsylvania, Washington and New Jersey.
Reversed courseNew Mexico — Gov. Michelle Lujan Grisham said no in August 2025, then announced participation Nov. 4, 2026.

Six states flipped from Republican to Democratic governors in the November 2026 midterms — Alaska, Georgia, Iowa, Nevada, Ohio and Texas — and all six had already opted in. Colorado’s governor-elect, Phil Weiser, is a “firm no” for 2028.

The split among Democratic governors is the story. Four Democratic-led states indicated participation — Colorado, New York, New Mexico and, until this decision, Virginia — while Minnesota, Oregon and Hawaii said no. And Virginia may be a test case for a new pattern: six states flipped from Republican to Democratic governors in the November 2026 midterms, and all six had already opted in. Education Week and K-12 Dive both note that incoming Democratic governors could withhold their scholarship lists just as Spanberger did.

What people are saying

The reaction split along familiar lines — and locally, too. The Virginia Education Association praised the decision: “VEA members applaud Governor Spanberger's wisdom in opting the Commonwealth out of the federal voucher program.” Its president, Carol Bauer, said “ample evidence tells us that voucher programs are damaging to public schools and students, draining resources from already underfunded school systems.”

On the other side, Bessent posted that Spanberger was “slamming the door on education scholarships for Virginia children, including students in PUBLIC schools … Stop playing politics with children's futures.” Youngkin posted that “1.4 million Virginia students are counting on you,” and told Fox News that public schools would be the main beneficiary and that Spanberger was removing $1.5 billion from families' pockets. CatholicVote called it “a heartbreaking betrayal of Virginia's families.” The Jewish Federations of North America called it an “unfortunate decision,” the National Catholic Educational Association said it was “deeply disappointed — and frankly shocked,” and the Virginia House Republican Caucus called it “a betrayal.” Del. Karen Hamilton posted a video saying she was “pretty fired up” because the program was “100% voluntary and privately funded.”

The split played out on school boards as well. Chesapeake's board voted 7–2 on Oct. 12 to back participation — board chair Kim Scott: “I want Virginia dollars in Virginia.” Suffolk's board put off a resolution asking Spanberger to opt out, then removed it from the agenda.

On social media, the posts that surface skew heavily critical of Spanberger — the Richmond Times-Dispatch's post drew hundreds of comments split along pro-public-school and pro-school-choice lines, and Youngkin's clip of his Fox News appearance drew thousands of likes and hundreds of comments, mostly polarized along party lines. But there is no poll and no representative analysis of what Virginians think, so the loudest posts are not a measure of Virginia opinion. The arguments for the opt-out appear mostly in institutional statements — the governor's office, the teachers union — rather than in the individual posts that surface online.

What happens next has three dates on it. The scholarship list is due Feb. 15, 2027, and Spanberger could still file it. States may opt in for 2028 starting Jan. 2, 2027. And when the General Assembly meets in January, HB 359 — a bill to put state testing and other rules on private schools taking tax-credit scholarships — returns for the 2027 session.

Stay connected to what's happening in Fredericksburg

Stories like this one are why we love this community. Join the GoFXBG Facebook page for local news, events, and the good stuff happening around town, and tell us in the comments what you'd like to see next.

Share
Enjoyed this article? Share it