What sets Tilly’s apart is their commitment to maintaining the balance between tradition and innovation. Their classic flavors—Chocolate, Strawberry, and Vanilla—deliver that familiar comfort that transports customers back to childhood summers, while signature specialties keep regulars coming back to discover what’s new.
The Butter Pecan offers a harmonious blend of creamy butter base with crisp, fresh pecans scattered throughout, creating a textural experience that exemplifies Tilly’s attention to quality and detail.
Beyond the Classics
Beyond the traditional favorites, Tilly’s specialty lineup shows their creative approach to frozen treats. The Salted Caramel Snickers has quickly emerged as a customer favorite, featuring rich caramel ice cream generously streaked with salted caramel and substantial chunks of Snickers candy bars. Each spoonful delivers the perfect combination of sweet, salty, chewy, and creamy textures.
Similarly, their Irish Chocolate Crumb has developed something of a cult following, with locals frequently bringing out-of-town visitors specifically to try this signature flavor.
The Cotton Candy and Mint Chocolate Chip options cater to those seeking familiar favorites with Tilly’s exceptional quality standard. Their Mint Chocolate Chip achieves the perfect balance—refreshingly cool mint ice cream studded with just the right amount of dark chocolate pieces that provide a satisfying snap in each bite.
Meanwhile, the Creamy Coffee flavor offers coffee enthusiasts a straightforward but perfectly executed rendition of their favorite beverage in frozen form, making it an ideal afternoon pick-me-up on hot summer days.
Dietary Inclusion
In recent years, Tilly’s has enthusiastically embraced the growing demand for inclusive dessert options, recognizing that dietary restrictions shouldn’t mean dessert deprivation. Their Vegan Chocolate GF Oreo has become surprisingly popular, even among customers with no dietary restrictions, thanks to its coconut base that creates an exceptionally creamy texture indistinguishable from traditional ice cream.
The generous chunks of gluten-free Oreos throughout provide the authentic cookies-and-cream experience that everyone deserves to enjoy, regardless of dietary needs.
The separate gluten-free Oreo option further demonstrates their commitment to accessibility while maintaining the classic flavor profile that Oreo lovers crave. Plant-based eaters particularly appreciate that Tilly’s approaches their vegan options with the same dedication to flavor and texture as their conventional offerings—never as an afterthought.
The inclusion of these specialty items reflects Tilly’s broader philosophy that ice cream is a universal joy that should be available to everyone in the community they serve, reinforcing their position as not just an ice cream shop but a neighborhood institution.
Top Seller Spotlight
Perhaps no flavor better represents Tilly’s blend of quality and tradition than their beloved Banana Pudding. This customer favorite faithfully recreates grandmother’s homemade banana pudding with its perfect combination of sweet banana pudding base, chunks of fresh banana, and authentic vanilla wafers.
The flavor consistently ranks among their top sellers, particularly among longtime residents who appreciate its ability to evoke childhood memories of family gatherings and summer picnics.
