Christian leaders hold a profound responsibility to guide their followers in truth, as defined by God’s Word. The Bible warns us about the dangers of false teachings and the need to test all guidance against Scripture (2 Timothy 4:3-4, James 3:1). In this piece, we will examine the teachings and public actions of Joel Osteen and Bishop Marianne Budde through a biblical lens, focusing on whether their guidance aligns with the call to lead people toward Christ.

Biblical Standards for Christian Leadership

Scripture provides clear qualifications and responsibilities for spiritual leaders. Leaders are called to be above reproach, sound in doctrine, and devoted to teaching God’s truth (1 Timothy 3:1-7, Titus 1:7-9). They must encourage believers and refute false teachings while holding fast to the faithful Word (Titus 1:9). Additionally, they are tasked with preaching the gospel of Christ—a message centered on repentance, faith, and submission to God’s will (Mark 1:15, Acts 20:21).

Any deviation from these principles should be examined with discernment, as Paul warns in Galatians 1:8-9: “But even if we or an angel from heaven should preach a gospel other than the one we preached to you, let them be under God’s curse.”

Joel Osteen’s Teachings

Joel Osteen is widely known for his optimistic and prosperity-focused messages, often centered on personal success and happiness. While his sermons appeal to a broad audience, many have criticized them for lacking the foundational truths of the gospel. Consider the following issues:

  1. Focus on Prosperity: Osteen often emphasizes financial success, health, and personal fulfillment. However, Jesus warns against storing up treasures on earth (Matthew 6:19-21) and prioritizing material wealth over spiritual riches (1 Timothy 6:10). Christ’s message is one of self-denial, not self-indulgence (Luke 9:23).
  2. Neglect of Sin and Repentance: Osteen’s sermons rarely address sin, repentance, or the need for salvation through Christ. Yet, the core of the gospel is the recognition of human sinfulness and the call to repentance (Romans 3:23, Acts 3:19). Paul’s charge to Timothy underscores the importance of preaching the full counsel of God, even when it is uncomfortable (2 Timothy 4:2).

By focusing on a “feel-good” message, Osteen’s teachings risk leading people away from the transformative truth of the gospel.

Bishop Marianne Budde’s Recent Comments

Bishop Marianne Budde’s leadership and recent public statements, particularly those addressing  President Donald Trump, have drawn attention and controversy. While speaking out on social or political issues is not inherently wrong, her approach raises questions when examined through Scripture:

  1. The Role of a Christian Leader in Witness: Budde’s comments have sometimes reflected more political alignment than gospel-centered focus. Paul reminds us that Christians are ambassadors of Christ, called to implore others to be reconciled to God (2 Corinthians 5:20). A leader’s primary mission is to point people to Christ, not to political ideologies.
  2. Tone and Humility: Scripture calls leaders to correct with gentleness and humility (2 Timothy 2:24-26, Galatians 6:1). Public rebukes, especially when they lack grace or focus on personal animosity, can detract from the gospel’s witness and bring division rather than unity.
  3. Testimony to the World: Jesus prayed for His followers to be in the world but not of it (John 17:15-19). The church’s mission is to reflect Christ’s character and truth, avoiding the temptation to conform to worldly agendas (Romans 12:2). Leaders like Budde must ensure their actions and words prioritize gospel proclamation above cultural or political narratives.

Conclusion

Both Joel Osteen and Bishop Marianne Budde, despite their influence, fall short in guiding people toward Christ when their teachings and actions are tested against Scripture. Osteen’s emphasis on prosperity and neglect of repentance risks leading people into a superficial faith that lacks the transformative power of the gospel. Budde’s politically charged statements and approach detract from the humility and Christ-centered focus required of Christian leaders.

As followers of Christ, we are called to test all teachings and leadership against the Word of God (1 John 4:1, Acts 17:11). Leaders must prioritize the truth of Scripture above cultural relevance or personal agendas. Let us pray for discernment and courage to follow leaders who faithfully proclaim the gospel of Jesus Christ, leading others to repentance and salvation in Him.